|
Careful
Bible students have long recognized a problem in the use of the
article "the" before "law" in passages where
the interpretation may vary, depending on the presence or absence
of that article. (See quote in P.T., V.17, N.4, from A. Campbell.)
Unfortunately, the translators seem to have been a bit arbitrary
by inserting "the" in many places where no article
exists in the Greek text. We give below some quotes from Grammar
of the Greek N.T., by A.T. Robertson.
"The
article is associated with gesture and aids in pointing out like
an index finger ... Whenever the Greek article occurs, the object
is certainly definite. When it is not used, the object may or may
not be...
The
translators of the King James version, under the influence of the
Vulgate, handle the Greek article loosely and inaccurately. A
goodly list of such sins is given in "The Revision of the N.T."
(Lightfoot, Ellicott, Trench), such as 'a pinnacle' for to pterugion
(Matt. 4:5). Here the whole point lies in the article, the wing of
the Temple overlooking the abyss. So in Matt. 5:1 to oros
was the mountain right at hand, not 'a mountain.' On the other
hand, the King James translators missed the point of meta gunaikos
(Jn. 4:27) when they said 'the woman." It was 'a woman,' any
woman, not the particular woman in question." (Page 756.)
Regarding
"law" (nomos) Robertson is a bit inconsistent. In
his large Grammar he says, "Nomos is a word that is
used with a deal of freedom by Paul. In general when nomos
is anarthrous (without the article, rt)
| |
in Paul it refers to the Mosaic law, as
in Rom. 2:17.... It is at least problematical whether nomos in
2:13... means the Mosaic law and so really definite, or law as law
(the hearers of law, the doers of law)." (p.796)
But
in Robertson's Word Studies, in Romans and Galatians, he
recognizes the absence of the article as indicating law
generally ("any law" he says); so he does not stick to
his statement that Paul's anarthrous law refers to Moses' law.
Actually, the context determines these matters in many cases —
especially in Romans and Galatians. Note Romans 3:20-21, the K.J.,
with "the" inserted or removed according to Nestle's
Greek text.
"Therefore
by deeds of law there shall no flesh be justified in his sight:
for by law is knowledge of sin. But now righteous of God without
law is manifested, being witnessed by the law and the
prophets."
Justification
(being pronounced 'free of guilt') is not on a law basis
("for all have sinned..."v.23) and law (any law) only
makes sin the more apparent (v.19, 5:20, 7:13); but God's plan for
righteousness is one of mercy, redemption through Christ's death
on our behalf (v.24-25), so that we who are less than perfect may
be forgiven-- pronounced free of guilt. And this plan was
"witnessed by the law" (of Moses) and the
prophets of old. There is no less "law" (necessity for
obedience) in Christ than in Moses, but the "curse" of a
law system which demanded perfection (Gal. 3:10 is replaced
by mercy, as the law testified.
[Previous
Article] [Next
Article]
|